SOUTHEASTFLORIDA.com REAL ESTATE . LOCAL INSIGHT . COASTAL LIFE.
Wiley Lulfs · LoKation Real Estate
Call Wiley 561-320-3055 If unavailable, your call will be forwarded to a Lulfs team member.
Homepage
Current MLS Property Details

58652 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050

Marathon, FL, 33050
58652 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050
1 / 18
Buyer Decision Center

Personal Property Evaluator

See what Wiley Lulfs notices in the MLS data, which details deserve a closer look, and how the asking price compares with a carefully matched group of recent sales.

Evaluate This Property
MLS # A12056681
At a Glance

Property Snapshot

The MLS currently describes this as a 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, 2,429 square feet, built in 1,981.

What Stands Out

Waterfront property
Private pool
Price reduced from original list price

About This Property

Enter the bougainvillea-lined gates of Casa Feliz, a private oceanfront retreat on Grassy Key with expansive water views, white sand beach, and a true resort-style experience in the Florida Keys. An exceptional investment opportunity, Casa Feliz is a strong producing vacation rental with rental history and future bookings already in place. Set on over 24,000 square feet of lush grounds with mature landscaping, fruit trees, fresh herbs, and .29 acres of bay bottom, this exceptional estate is designed for both relaxation and entertaining. An observation pier invites kayaking, paddleboarding, fishing, and endless enjoyment of marine life, while the unique orientation captures both breathtaking sunrise and sunset views over the water, a rare and coveted feature in the Keys. Outdoor living is elevated with a resort-style saltwater pool featuring cascading waterfalls, spillover spa, and fully equipped poolside cabana complete with wet bar, refrigerator, ice maker, and cooking area. A fire table and beachside fire pit create the ultimate setting for entertaining or unwinding beneath the stars. Completely renovated down to the studs in 2022, the three-story residence was thoughtfully redesigned to maximize sweeping ocean views from nearly every room. Offering four custom bedroom suites, each with private en-suite bath, the home comfortably accommodates guests in luxury.

Property Details

Property Type Single Family Residence
Subdivision Crains Sub
Development Crains Sub
County Monroe
Waterfront Yes
Private Pool Yes
Original List Price $3,650,000
MLS ID A12056681
Updated Sep 9, 2026
Quick Payment Estimate

What might this home cost each month?

Starting rate: 6.66% 30 year fixed national average · updated Aug. 27, 2026
$
%
%
$ /mo
Estimated principal & interest $0/mo
P&I + HOA / condo $0/mo
Taxes, insurance, flood coverage and PMI are not included here. Rate is editable and is not a lender quote.
Listing Office: Ocean Sotheby's International • 305-735-4095
Listing Agent: Jo Ann Cook • 305-360-7968
MLS ID: A12056681
Property information is displayed from the site's BeachesMLS IDX data feed. Information is subject to change and should be independently verified.
Property Location

Where is this property?

58652 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050 · Marathon, FL, 33050
Loading map…
Explore South Florida homes on the full map →